Aug 20 Sacramento
state_capitol
Schwarzenegger Praises Minuteman Volunteers
Published: April 29, 2005

SACRAMENTO—Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger, who outraged some Mexican-American groups last week by calling for a closed border, has praised the Minuteman Project in which hundreds of volunteers have been patrolling the Arizona-Mexico boundary to spot illegal crossers.

“I think they’ve done a terrific job, and look, they’ve cut down the crossing of illegal immigrants by a huge percentage,” Schwarzenegger said in an interview Thursday on KFI-AM’s “The John & Ken Show.”

The Republican governor accused the federal government of failing to control the borders and, in fact, encouraging illicit crossers by providing them access to water.

“The whole system is set up to really invite people to come in here illegally, and that has to stop,” he said.

The so-called Minuteman Project involves hundreds of volunteers, some armed, who have been patrolling the Arizona border since April 1 to document and report incidents of illegal crossing.

Chris Simcox, a Minuteman organizer, said he welcomed Schwarzenegger’s support.

“It’s gratifying to see that elected officials are responding to the will of the people,” he said.

There are plans to expand the project to California in June.

Schwarzenegger “does not oppose” the group coming to California, said Margita Thompson, his press secretary.

President Bush has denounced the volunteers as vigilantes.

Nativo V. Lopez, president of the Mexican-American Political Association, called Schwarzenegger’s comments Thursday “nothing short of base racism.”

“Those of immigrant stock should have no illusions about what his real sentiments and feelings are toward them,” he said.

“It’s not racist to ask the federal government to enforce its laws,” Schwarzenegger’s press secretary said. “Everyone should be united in wanting to protect our national security.”

U.S. Sen. Dianne Feinstein, D-Calif., said she was surprised that Schwarzenegger would be “praising efforts by untrained volunteers to patrol the borders.”

“The best course would be to add an additional 2,000 border patrol agents,” she said.

Assemblyman Hector De La Torre, D-South Gate, called the governor’s comments “scapegoating and immigrant bashing.”

“To support vigilantism is completely against the oath he took” to uphold the law, De La Torre said.

Schwarzenegger’s comments came a week after he faced a barrage of criticism for telling a gathering of newspaper publishers that the United States needed to “close the borders.” He apologized the next day, blaming his faulty English and saying he really meant the borders should be secured.

During Thursday’s radio interview, Schwarzenegger also called on Spanish-language television station KRCA-TV to take down billboards that identify its market as “Los Angeles, Mexico.”

“It promotes illegal aliens to come in here,” the governor said.

Messages left after business hours Thursday at the Burbank offices of Liberman Broadcasting were not immediately returned. The company owns KRCA and three other Spanish-language TV stations in California and Texas.

Before Schwarzenegger’s comments, company executive vice president Lenard Liberman told the Los Angeles Times, “We tell the story behind LA, and we tell the story behind Mexico.”

Referring to critics of the ads, he said, “If they find that offensive, I’m sorry. But you just have to drive around LA to know that this is a Hispanic city.”

A report released in March by the Pew Hispanic Center estimates that about 11 million undocumented migrants now live in the United States, half of whom come from Mexico. California is home to 2.4 million, far more than any other state.

Reader's Comments
"2. Illegals spawn criminal acts against the legal citizens of our country:

a. Identity theft
b. drug trafficking
c. child smuggling for porn and prostitution.
d. taking the benefits without paying the price of our tax funded services.
e. by working under the table, they enable employers to pay wages that do not provide a living income.
f. in right to work states, they keep legal citizens from being able to keep their jobs because somebody is willing to take their place at an illegal wage."
-> Posted by breezy / May 30, 2006
"1. Illegals are locusts, they eat up our resources and our children's futures by draining our economy of taxes paid by legal citizens and shipping money made under the table back to Mexico or wherever else they came from."
-> Posted by breezy / May 30, 2006
"some of us are born wealthy this is why whe are not faced with having to make dangerouse choice like the ones ilegal imigants have to maketheme selves living in a place were they can t aford to feed their children its unexpected
some dont make it. we have to underatand them they do pay taxes even with a fake SS# What would you feel being societyes others going to the doctor only for emergencies they suffer so much you need to experince what they feel in orderto offend them in any way!"
-> Posted by linda / Nov 08, 2005
"we are all imigrants ever since christopher colombus came to what known know as the USA execpt for the the native americans I wonder why know thier so much hate for the mexican if they are the ones that briing positive social values are hard workers ext. I also wonder why Arnold doesnt like imigrants if he is a big imigant himself we should find a way to cope with the difernt races since suposely USA is a palsce of imigants."
-> Posted by linda / Nov 08, 2005
"sorry but you will have to read from the fist time i posted to read correctly, this comment forum is set wrong, didnt realize it set new posts at the top instead of the bottom like a normal forum."
-> Posted by mike h / Oct 05, 2005
"its about respect, right or wrong - if you cant respect us or our laws how can we respect you for breaking them......

If you want to live and work here and be happy do it the right way legally.

Now about the minutemen being Vigilantes it is the right of the people to protect the rights of its peoples when the govt wont.
The only reason the Illegal Immigrants don’t like this is the fact it raises % they will get caught and sent back to the conditions they left behind."
-> Posted by mike h / Oct 05, 2005
"part5
now for you people that like to put labels on people such as racist for example grow the heck up and go back to school we are all the same color on the inside, we are all human's and your just try to skew things to fit you own motivations or agenda nothing more.
if it takes close’n the border to get the Illegal Immigrants to legally enter this country so be it, lock it up tight as a drum"
-> Posted by mike h / Oct 05, 2005
"part 4
its not about who's on the other side of the border its about respecting our laws, if you don’t! then you have no rights here for medical help, assistants, educations, driver lic or anything that a legal citizen has a right to access in this country."
-> Posted by mike h / Oct 05, 2005
"part 3
if its hard liven in your country then stay and help fix the problem, by go in to a country as an illegal immigrant you are creating a problem by breaking the law..

its not about who will do a job that others don’t want to do or have done and gone on to better jobs, I for one have worked in the fields and moved on to a better work environment and wages.."
-> Posted by mike h / Oct 05, 2005
"Illegal immigrant = any human who has come to a country and settled there with out going through that countries legal process to do so...
This shows you don’t respect the laws of that country and are more app to keep break more of its laws.
Yes its not the best system i agree but its our system none the less. Also if you come here by break'n the laws then yes you’re not wanted here, its nothing more then economic terrorism."
-> Posted by mike h / Oct 05, 2005
"It seems most of you either doesn’t care, forgot or are trying to skew the process that’s in place so let’s define a few things here.

Legal immigrant = any human who has come to a country and settled there after going through the legal process to enter regardless of color or race..
by taken the time in doing this its shows that you respect the legal process of that country's laws and are less app to brake its laws one would hope."
-> Posted by mike h / Oct 05, 2005
"Assimilation? How can we assimate with these primitive life forms called Mexicans. They are about a hundred thousand light years behind us. I mean, they are human, sort of, no argument with that, but culturally who wants em. They make it sound like we need them to survive rather than the other way around. I mean they came up here to suck off us, not visa versa."
-> Posted by A Citizen / May 30, 2005
"To " you might be " :
We don't need to boycott. We fine those places where Illegals work.

AS for the lettuce? Wow, 50 cents? where do you shop? At any rate, given what we already pay in the SOCIAL services cost, you might as well say, we're paying $20.00 for letuce NOW!"
-> Posted by Leo of Sacramento / May 26, 2005
"My heritage is from Spain, Germany, Turkish, etc..., but I am also Hispanic, I do not call immigrants MEXICAN, because not all immigrants are MEXICAN, there are many other immigrants moving to the USA from many other Countries, let see you complain about the Chinese, Japanese, European, etc... No you can't complain about them since they are well under covered and not right next to the US to stereotype MEXICO."
-> Posted by So SAD / May 26, 2005
"To all against Immigrants, I’d like to consider the remote possibility that you are right, I’d like for you to walk the talk and boycott all rest. that have immigrants to wait on you, that grow the food you eat, boycott every supermarket that has immigrants to help you, every store that has immigrants, that helped in the prdctn of anything you use, wear or eat. If you can do that and go pay $2 for a lettuce picked by an AMERICAN and not a .50 lettuce picked by an Immigrant, then you are RIGHT."
-> Posted by you might be right / May 26, 2005
"To " dear Leo " :
You weren't " raced " mexican. Raised maybe. My Spanish decent is from my heritage of SPAIN.
Immigrants have it hard? Maybe the paperwork they have to fill out.
If you mean, the Illegals? Ah.....so?
Citizen of This country? Yet you say you were BORN mexican? Ah....No, if you were BORN here, You're an American, with a Mexican heritage.
Nice try."
-> Posted by Leo of Sacramento / May 26, 2005
"To " get informed " :
I'm not sure the average farm worker only gets $2.00 an hour anymore. As to Americans NOT wanting to do that job? Sure they would, we have LOTS of volunteers. They just don't know it yet.
You worry about citizens carrying weapons?
Must be an Illegal yourself, or else you'd KNOW citizens of this nation can carry weapons, where licensed.
Deaths of the Illegals? You mean, like the Coyotes who murder them? Oh...my bad, you FORGOT those people, in your ANTI-US rant.
Pffft"
-> Posted by Leo of Sacramento / May 26, 2005
"I am a born and raced Mexican, not (Mexican/Spanish) and I am proud of who I am, I am a citizen of this Country and happy to be here, I get so upset about people that try to act one way in some situations and another way in other, I respect everyone and sometimes I understand that if you do not know the struggles that Immgrnts go trough everyday because of people like your self that make it so diff. on them, they I pitty you."
-> Posted by Dear Leo / May 25, 2005
"When they talk about what a great job this minuteman are doing, then, why is it that they carry guns and they are not cops, why aren't they checked on how many rounds they shoot?, when we don't hear about all the children and immgrnts that are killed on the borders. let see if the americans that hate them so much will be happy to work the fields and get paid 2/hr let see if they will stop hiring them and let see who will be doing all their jobs for just a few $ to send back to their countries."
-> Posted by Get informed / May 25, 2005
"So, even tho they have fake SSN's, they pay taxes?? So....if they didn't? What then?
Think the law will go after them?? Pffft....they'd just hop back across the border, or change up the fake SSN.
Nice try, weak attempt."
-> Posted by Leo of Sacramento / May 25, 2005
"I do not get where you got that Illigals do not want to become legal, you might not know it, but still with a fake SS# they pay taxes, you might be not well informed about that, but they do want to become legal, that is one of the harder sturgles for imigrants in this country, I respect people, but I do not respect racist people."
-> Posted by Who told you that?? / May 25, 2005
"Illegals don't want to be legal. That would require them to get an "authentic" SS card and pay taxes like the rest of us, instead of working under the table and then sending all their money back to Mexico. While 11 billion dollars gets wired back to Mexico each year, illegals scam our systems using phony documents, getting free medical, welfare, tuition, food stamps and other services, while the California taxpayer gets the screw."
-> Posted by pb, santa cruz / May 24, 2005
"Ms Ily says in part : " mexican families come to support their families "
Yes they do, the ones who LEGALLY Immigrate here. What were the 48000 in jail doing? It sure wasn't fixing roofs.
We said Illegal Aliens. YOU said Mexicans.
Who's racist now?
BTW? Diz is coming from a proud Mexican/Spanish male, who wonders WHY his herritage allow themselves to be treated like offal?"
-> Posted by Leo of Sacramento / May 24, 2005
"i dont understand y he has to make a huge deal about it when he's focusing on the canadian border mexican families come to support their families they work hard out here when do u see an american or an asian american up on the roof fixing them or doing landscaping it's basicly mexican all he's about is racism .diz coming from a proud mexican gurl !!!!"
-> Posted by ily / May 24, 2005
"what part of illegal doesnt everyone understand? i if we cant have a system to check who is here how can we protect LEGAL americans?"
-> Posted by jj / May 19, 2005
"Please stop classifying illegal immigrants with legal immigrants. Being against illegal immigration is not anti-immigrant. The racism problem here is with those who have the attitude of "my race right or wrong." If a member of your race breaks the law and someone of another race doesn't like it, that doesn't automatically make that person a racist. Using accusations of racism to argue for illegal immigration is a cop-out and those who do so really have no other argument."
-> Posted by NoDeuce / Apr 29, 2005
"Are you sure he is not a racist??? He continues to attack the latin comunities, not only Mexican.Now even now African American's are on his side?? this is just not good. Legal or illigal immigrants from latin america have never been a terrorist offence to the US, so why is it now such a big deal, maybe since the latins will be soon the mayority."
-> Posted by Not a racist?? / Apr 29, 2005
"COMMON SENSE, BRAIN POWER. Most people have these capabilities. President promoted fear, the terrorist are gonna get us. President secure the border between America and Mexico. Maybe that is not in the master plan. As for the jobs Americans won't do, I say your wrong. I would start my own lawn care business if we could stop illegal immigration. Racist, hardly, I am Black. Didn't we do those jobs before the illegals got here?"
-> Posted by Tony Long / Apr 29, 2005
"Due to a lack of local reporting, the Minutemen got the most attention from Sacramento news outlets.
They however, overlooked the HOLD THEIR FEET TO THE FIRE group that went TOO Washington DC to demand enforcement of the laws. Between various talk show hosts, almost 1000 people, you'd think someone here in Sacramento would report that."
-> Posted by Leo of Sacramento / Apr 29, 2005
"The governor has the support of most of the citizens of California. Illegal Immigration and Legal Immigration are two totally different things, no matter how much supporters of illegal immigration want to blend the two. The MinuteMan project was a total success and should be continued along every inch of our southern border. Thank God some Americans and Legal Immigrants have the guts to Do The Right Thing."
-> Posted by Nan of Lakewood / Apr 29, 2005
"You ask someone, what " Illegal Immigrant " means, and they're likely to say, an Illegal Mexican in the US.

Wow....why would that be? Who cares that illegal immigrants are upset that they are the focus of so much attention. They are here Illegally.

As for those of the Minutemen project? Please, if you want to crucify them, then let's start slamming the Neighborhood Watch folks, those who HELP the police, etc etc etc. Vigilantes my backside."
-> Posted by Leo of Sacramento / Apr 29, 2005
"ILLEGAL Immigration is the problem, let us not forget. It spits in the faces of those who immigrated legally. I support efforts to reform the application processes to make them available to more people. However, I will never support my tax dollars funding illegal activity."
-> Posted by Miles Harris / Apr 29, 2005
"I can't believe how an immigrant can be attacking other immigrants just because we look darker than him. He should first learn how to speak English correctly and not having to apologize "because of my faulty English".This Minuteman project is bad and this should not be accepted among all immigrants. I hope that someone will stop cheering this so call Governor/Actor and think about what will happened the day that there aren't any immigrants to work for them."
-> Posted by Ana L Ojeda / Apr 29, 2005
Post Your Comments
Your Name:
Your Comment:
Email (will not be shown on posts)
Notify you of follow-up comments?
Please enter the word you see in the image below
  
Printable Version Email Article